The first garden strawberry was grown in Brittany, France, during the late 18th century. He also sells them on his Etsy shop. Both beaver sexes have a pair of castor sacs and a pair of anal glands, located in two cavities under the skin between the pelvis and the base of the tail. Two subspecies of F. vesca were identified: F. sylvestris alba and F. sylvestris semperflorens. Aftel, who also makes a line of chefs flavorings, has not used castoreum in edible concoctions, but points out that other heavily scented animal glands and secretionsmusk, civet, and ambergriswere luxury ingredients in Medieval banquets. Is fake strawberry really beaver butt? a guy once asked me after a talk I gave on the history of synthetic flavors. It is important to understand that just because natural flavors come from something natural, does not necessarily make them healthy. For much of its history, castoreum was used as a medicine. All content 2019 by Eric Troy and CulinaryLore. Because of this, according to Fenaroli's Handbook of Flavor Ingredients, only roughly 300 pounds are produced annually.Instead of being put into desserts like baked goods and ice creams, the castoreum is often used in the perfume industry to add sweet scents to . That is one expensive flavor ingredient. I sell a plastic shopping bag full of dried frozen castors every month, he told me, though he couldnt quite say whos buying them or why. Kraft American Cheese Burns Instead of Melts When Exposed to Direct Flame? Well, the first port of call on this discovery trail is to consider the relationship between beaver butts and flavors. The confusion probably comes from not understanding the difference between vanilla flavor and vanilla flavored products. Its the mood of the forest, evoking both the beaver and its woodland home, according to Matt Power, a master distiller at Tamworth who helped develop the beverage. And in 2011, the Vegetarian Resource Group asked five companies that make vanilla flavoring if they used any beaver extract. Castoreum is so favorably fragrant that we've been using it to flavor ice cream, chewing gum, pudding and brownies -- basically anything that could use a vanilla, raspberry or strawberry substitute -- for at least 80 years. Castoreum is also used in perfumes for a musky scent or to give leather overtones, as well as to help preserve the fragrance for longer. Strawberries are a good source of vitamin C, manganese, folate (vitamin B9 . The primary flavor constituent will be a fruit extractive or the major flavor or aroma compound for the fruit flavor desired. [45], In the United States in 2017, the collective commercial production of strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries was a $6billion industry dominated by the California growing and marketing company Driscoll's. They took the stance the move to cochineal was to move away from artificial ingredients. This, as they discovered, resulted in an increase in honey production. But if it was being used in flavorings, I knew there was only one reason for it: It must be delicious. [53][54] Although achenes comprise only about 1% of total fresh weight of a strawberry, they contribute 11% of the total polyphenol in the whole fruit; achene phytochemicals include ellagic acid, ellagic acid glycosides, and ellagitannins. In England the demand for regular strawberry farming had increased by the mid-16th century. Tamworth gets its castoreum from Anton Kaska, a local New Hampshire trapper, who harvests castor sacs from nuisance beavers hes hired to destroy. So, not only is it unlawful to use castoreum in avanilla extract, it is highly unlikely that many food companies would want to use it as a flavoring ingredient at all, being that there are much cheaper alternatives. For example, the ghost moth is known to be a pest of the strawberry plant. I sell a plastic shopping bag full of dried frozen castors every month, he told me, though he couldnt quite say whos buying them or why. Production spread to Arkansas, Louisiana, Florida, and Tennessee. Or, if you are thinking of adding raspberries or strawberries to your smoothy, then youll need one of the Best Personal Blenders you can buy in 2023. August 14, 2017. Sterbenz, Christina. Roman women inhaled the fumes of smoldering castoreum in an attempt to induce abortions. Depending on area, strawberry pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, or strawberry shortcake are also common. I also knew, from conversations Id had with people who work in the flavor industry, that it was increasingly rare. Due the relatively fragile nature of the strawberry, approximately 35 percent of the $2.2 billion United States crop was spoiled in 2020. Beavers are generally no longer hunted for their pelts or castoreum, so to acquire the sticky stuff, beavers must be anesthetized and the castoreum gland milked by a human. In 1982, according to the Flavor Extract Manufacturers Association (FEMA), 683 pounds of castoreum were used in flavorings in the US. All flavors, whether naturally present in food or artificially created, are made of chemical compounds. In 2004, the food industry used only about 300 pounds of the beaver extract, according to according to the fifth edition of Fenaroli's Handbook of Flavor Ingredients, an industry bible of sorts. There are normally adequate levels of phosphorus and potash when fields have been fertilized for top yields. Foodblogalliance.comis part of ChefsResource and is controlled by Ask The Experts LLC. In 1894, a representative of the Hudson Bay Company, a major beaver pelt and castoreum trading firm, said: "The beavers days are numbered. Now, we know what youre thinking. These flavors can be obtained by heating or roasting . I have an idea why not use real strawberries? A few years ago, celebrity chef Jamie Oliver kicked up a foodie firestorm when he told the audience at the Late Show with David Letterman that vanilla ice cream contains flavoring from a beaver's um, derriere. Sit back and take a look around. It comes from the female Dactylopius coccus and takes 70,000 carcasses to make 1 pound of cochineal. Decades ago, scientists used compounds extracted from a gland in a beaver's tush to help create strawberry and raspberry flavorings or enhance vanilla substitutes. Oliver told audiences that strawberry syrups contained flavorings that essentially originated from the behind of the beaver. Photo courtesy of Tamworth Distilling, There is a traditional castoreum-flavored spirit: Bverhojt, a schnapps typically consumed by Swedish trappers before heading out for a day hunting game. I also wonder exactly where I can get an expensive strawberry syrup. Now you can see this is starting to become a whole lot clearer. [30] The crown and roots may fall victim to red stele, verticillium wilt, black root rot, and nematodes. Thats right, the ingredient is so dangerous that its usage in breast plant production was perdominantly halted. I know it may be hard to believe but after a lot of processing, it is considered a legal "natural flavoring" and will be listed as such in an ingredient list. Does artificial strawberry contain strawberry? Hildegard von Bingen, a 12th-century Benedictine abbess, mystic, and scholar, wrote that powdered beaver testicles drunk in wine would reduce a fever; the castoreum gland, when dried, is easily mistaken for testes. Strawberries are popular in home gardens, and numerous cultivars have been selected for consumption and for exhibition purposes. [17] Similar results in an earlier study conducted by USDA confirms how compost plays a role in the bioactive qualities of two strawberry cultivars.[18]. But the biggest problem with castoreum was not its price, nor its anal-adjacent origins. The industry is closely watching this year's harvest . And with that refresher on biology, we can all go safely back to enjoying a cup of vanilla ice cream with strawberry syrup drizzled on top. Artificial Raspberry Flavorings. "I tell them, 'Oh, but its beavers; it smells really good.'". Sold in drugstores and pharmacies, it was recommended for earaches, toothaches, colic, gout, inducing sleep, preventing sleep, and general strengthening of the brain. [23], To maintain top quality, berries are harvested at least every other day. The culprit behind this scare is a flavorant called castoreumbut what exactly is it, and is it worth all the fuss? Meg Vogel/NPR A raspberry, strawberry, or another fruit flavoring may contain all-natural ingredients or a mixture of natural and artificially derived ingredients. The introduction of F. virginiana from eastern North America to Europe in the 17th century is an important part of history because it is one of the two species that gave rise to the modern strawberry. The strawberry aphid, Chaetosiphon fragaefolii, is a bug species found in the United States (Arizona), Argentina and Chile. Similarly, castoreum itself is not a vanilla flavor. [34], The plants can also develop disease from temperature extremes during winter. The fruit is widely appreciated for its characteristic aroma, bright red color, juicy texture, and sweetness. [19] Seeds (achenes) are acquired either via commercial seed suppliers, or by collecting and saving them from the fruit. It's too expensive and cumbersome (and gross) a process to extract. During testing an enzymatic reaction occurred, turning the aldehydes into alcohols. If an internal link led you here, you may wish to change the link to point directly to the intended article. . You may notice that most raspberry and strawberry flavor extracts do declare this. Consumers Tell Starbucks to go Organic and Drop GMO-Milk, 8 Proofs We Dont Need GMOs to Feed the World, Alaska Fishermen Concerned GM Salmon Could Harm $6.4 Billion Fishing Industry, How Soybean Oil Consumption Ballooned by 1000x in 100 Years, Toxic Weedkiller Dicamba Drift Damages Crops Across America. Their Eau de Musc, released this summer, is a bourbon flavored with castoreum along with regional White Mountain botanicals: fir tips, sweet birch, wild ginger, Canadian snakeroot. The answer is yes, there is a food additive called castoreum that is derived from certain glands of the beaver and it can be used as a flavoring ingredient in foods. So it ends up being a very expensive product and not very popular with food companies.". Zero Sugar Takes 2 to Mango Tea. 2y ago. Suppress Coughs by Coating the Throat inChocolate? Castoreum is a substance secreted by male and female Alaskan, Canadian, and Siberian beavers from pouchlike sacs located near the base of their tails (castor is the word for beaver in Latin). In some cases all you need is one molecule to give you the flavor's essence and for you to make that instant connection. It is consumed in large quantities, either fresh or in such prepared foods as jam, juice, pies, ice cream, milkshakes, and chocolates. Opting to save money in blatant disregard for public health, the highly complex chemical formulas consist of a long list of substances includingamyl acetate,benzyl isobutyrate, and phenethyl alcohol. It is what people refer to when they talk about strawberry and raspberry flavors coming from beavers glands. Watermelon is particularly hard to make. Does strawberry flavoring come from a beaver? [10], Strawberry cultivars vary widely in size, color, flavor, shape, degree of fertility, season of ripening, liability to disease and constitution of plant. Charles V, France's king from 1364 to 1380, had 1,200 strawberry plants in his royal garden. So, this part, at least, is not a myth. Strawberry . And then they would use the potion to help create strawberry and raspberry flavorings or to enhance vanilla substitutes. The colonization of America led into an increase in the availability of beaver pelts, which were used to make fine hats all over Europe, and to a resurgence of interest in castoreum as medicine. As mentioned, it is produced in the castor glands. Theres so much more to discover about this. Castoreum began to be used in flavorings in the early 20th century, an era when flavor-makers were borrowing freely from perfumers toolkits. It can simply be listed asnatural flavoring. Castoreum could be found in beverages, baked goods, ice cream, candy, and especially in chewing gum. Out of the original bag of the four original flavors, the orange Starburst has been voted second to last in a survey done by Mashed. The 15th-century Persian Nimatnamah, knows in English as the Sultans Book of Delights, includes recipes for musk-spiced samosas and ambergris-and-rosewater puddings. Please do not use my images without prior permission. The reason these alcohols were thought to be primarily responsible for watermelon's aroma is due to how the study was conducted. [9], Research published in 2001 showed that strawberries actually occur in three basic flowering habits: short-day, long-day, and day-neutral. Then an early-spring heat wave pushed the plants along. Nevertheless, the FDA considers it a natural flavor, since it is derived from a natural source, and can be used to add fruity strawberry or raspberry notes, or as substitute for vanilla (the compounds come from the beaver's diet of bark and leaves). Chipotle Secret Menu Items You Didnt Know About. This story of getting Raspberry or Strawberry Flavor from Beaver Glands has been going around for a long time now. Variety Pack No.3 - 12 pack This is just unrealistic. Log in. So while it's hard to know what foods or fragrances contain castoreum, there is very little of it out there. Natural Flavors and Food Allergens. coffee beans that are dug out of civet poop, http://www.terradaily.com/reports/Japanese_Researchers_Extract_Vanilla_From_Cow_Dung.html, Travel: Random Tips and Trivia from an Old Backpacking Dog | Laura Zera, Year-end Fun: Updates on Past Posts Travel & More - Laura Zera, Travel: My Cup of Wild Civet Coffee - Laura Zera. Soon after, Antoine Nicolas Duchesne began to study the breeding of strawberries and made several discoveries crucial to the science of plant breeding, such as the sexual reproduction of the strawberry which he published in 1766. [56], As strawberry flavor and fragrance are characteristics that may appeal to consumers,[46][48][57] they are used widely in a variety of manufacturing, including foods, beverages, confections, perfumes and cosmetics. It is in amphibians, reptiles, birds, elasmobranch fishes (such as sharks), and monotremes, but most mammals do not have it. For instance, strawberry flavor does not always come from strawberries or blueberry flavor from blueberries. Why Less Than 1% Of Obese Individuals Will Reach Normal Weight, Fat-Shaming Doesnt Work and Can Increase Health Risks, Its a Mindset: In Order to Get Fit, You Must THINK of Yourself as Fit, Mindful Eating Shown to Help People Lose Weight, FDA Warns Against Disease-Killing Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy, Acetaminophen may Increase Stroke Risk in People with Diabetes, Exciting: New Seaweed-Based Alzheimers Drug Shows Extreme Promise, Study: Birth Control Pills can Lower Womens Quality of Life, Bernie Sanders Interview Cancelled Because Monsanto Was Threatening to Sue, Worlds Largest Bee, Thought to be Extinct, Spotted in Indonesia, Yikes: U.S. The FDA requires that companies disclose if their product contains one of the eight major food allergens: milk, eggs, wheat, soy, fish, shellfish, peanuts, or tree nuts. Every batch of the natural strawberry flavor offered by Advanced Biotech is as flavorful as the next, as well, due to . This chemical compound is used by beavers to mark their territory. A beaver has two glands known as castor glands. October 7, 2022 by Ashfakur. LorAnn Super-Strength Strawberry Flavor, 16 Ounce. The flavorists sample the fruit and use a variety of different adjectives to describe the tastes that they experience from a subjective standpoint, similar to the way that a sommelier might sample wine . The chemical concoction consists of 50 different chemical ingredients, many of which could be threatening to your health. Ive Heard People Say Vanilla Flavor Also Comes From Beaver Glands, Is This True? It smells like an old cowboy, Kaska said to me. "It was created to appeal to the children's market, as well as . The vanilla flavoring in confectionary products is actually Castoreum. Developed By, Discover an Effective, Easy, and Inexpensive Heavy Metal Detox Agent, Good News: Blushwood Berries Kill Cancer in 75% of Cases, Big Pharma Tackles Patent, 7 Natural Anti-Anxiety Herbs to Reduce Stress, Microwave Dangers Why You Should Not Use a Microwave, Toxic BPA Substitute BPS Chemical More Dangerous than BPA, EWG Report: Your Tap Water is Contaminated with Toxic Forever Chemicals, Is Non-Toxic Nail Polish Really Non-Toxic? Once the 8 weeks have passed, strain the mixture through cheesecloth. Nature is out of balance. Vanilla is another flavor that often contains castoreum, just like raspberry and strawberry. Nitrogen fertilizer is needed at the beginning of every planting year. Journal of Biological Chemistry , 2013; DOI: 10.1074/jbc.M113.453852 Cite . Castor is French for beaver, and castor oil got its name from the animal because of the oils usefulness in replacing castoreum. A few seed-propagated cultivars have been developed for home use, and research into growing from seed commercially is ongoing. [33], A 1997 study assessed many wound volatiles and found all effective against gray mold (B. The flower buds formed last fall and were tucked away under a layer of straw for the winter. If food companies wanted to earn the rabbinical seal of approval, any traces of castoreum in flavorings had to be nixed. Its leathery and powdery, woody, slightly astringent, with a shadowy trace of berries. The perfumer-historian Mandy Aftel described it to me as kind of sexy, kind of darkthe scent of Russian leather. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. What's Flavoring Your Pastry? I just wanted to share with you the typical ingredients found in the chemical makeup of strawberry flavor: hydroxyphenyl-2-butanone (10 percent solution in alcohol). In most cases, the flowers appear hermaphroditic in structure, but function as either male or female. Licorice made in the U.S. is usually flavored with other compounds without the root extract, glycyrrhizin, also known as glycyrrhizic acid, the compound that makes licorice sweet and gives it that signature taste. The secretion and the smell that comes from it is sometimes calledbeaver taint. So when I heard there was a new bourbon flavored with castoreum, I knew I had to try it. The chances of your raspberry or strawberry syrup coming from anywhere near a beavers backside is fairly slim indeed. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Welcome to our 10th year of providing you with delicious, healthy meals. With a crisp, clean finish, this juicy flavor is both refreshing and sessionable. Castoreum is a quintessential secret ingredient, something that made a flavor better and more interesting, while eluding recognition. [51], Garden strawberries contain the dimeric ellagitannin agrimoniin which is an isomer of sanguiin H-6. All flavors, whether naturally present in food or artificially created, are made of chemical.. But its beavers ; it was created to appeal to the children & # x27 s... Use my images without prior permission a talk I gave on the history synthetic... Chemical ingredients, many of which could be threatening to your health out there an of. Is just unrealistic it, and sweetness coccus and takes 70,000 carcasses to make 1 pound cochineal... Normally adequate levels of phosphorus and potash when fields have been selected for consumption for. Not necessarily make them healthy its beavers ; it was created to appeal the. Includes recipes for musk-spiced samosas and ambergris-and-rosewater puddings and in 2011, the first port of call this! Color, juicy texture, and research into growing from seed commercially is ongoing if it was increasingly rare commercial! Plants in his royal garden extracts do declare this that often contains castoreum, I knew there was one... It is important to understand that just because natural flavors come from something natural, does not always from! And takes 70,000 carcasses to make 1 pound of cochineal and found all effective gray!, where does strawberry flavoring come from ( vitamin B9 the ingredient is so dangerous that its usage breast! Is an isomer of sanguiin H-6 Direct Flame very little of it out there without permission... Butts and flavors Russian leather 20th century, an era when flavor-makers were borrowing freely from toolkits! A crisp, clean finish, this part, at least, is True... Fruit is widely appreciated for its characteristic aroma, bright red color, juicy texture, sweetness! The early 20th century, an era when flavor-makers were borrowing freely from perfumers toolkits flavoring... Plants in his royal garden they discovered, resulted in an increase in honey production production perdominantly. See this is just unrealistic these flavors can be obtained by heating or.... Also develop disease from temperature extremes during winter of which could be found in the flavor industry that... An increase in honey production contain the dimeric ellagitannin agrimoniin which is an isomer of sanguiin H-6 had 1,200 plants! The vanilla flavoring in confectionary products is actually castoreum from the female Dactylopius coccus and takes 70,000 carcasses make. And castor oil got its name from the animal because of the strawberry, approximately 35 of... An expensive strawberry syrup important to understand that just because natural flavors come from strawberries or flavor. Major flavor or aroma compound for the fruit wilt, black root rot, sweetness... Wonder exactly where I can get an expensive strawberry syrup coming from anywhere near a beavers backside is fairly indeed! Farming had increased by the mid-16th century Experts LLC and then they would use the potion to help create and. Made of chemical compounds strawberry farming had increased by the mid-16th century turning! Gray mold ( B fragaefolii, is a flavorant called castoreumbut what exactly it! Vitamin B9 backside is fairly slim indeed asked five companies that make flavoring... Developed for home use, and research into growing from seed commercially is ongoing ingredients, many of could! Use real strawberries and numerous cultivars have been selected for consumption and for exhibition purposes audiences that syrups... Exposed to Direct Flame perfumers toolkits the relatively fragile nature where does strawberry flavoring come from the natural flavor. Food or artificially created, are made of chemical compounds what people refer to when talk. By Advanced Biotech is as flavorful as the Sultans Book of Delights, includes for. Chemical compound is used by beavers to mark their territory example, the Vegetarian Resource Group asked companies! The flower buds formed last fall and were tucked away under a layer of for... The vanilla flavoring if they used any beaver extract increasingly rare Chemistry, 2013 ; DOI: 10.1074/jbc.M113.453852 Cite well... From the female Dactylopius coccus and takes 70,000 carcasses to make 1 pound of cochineal first garden strawberry was in! Also knew, from conversations Id had with people who work in the United States crop was spoiled 2020! I Heard there was a new bourbon flavored with castoreum was used as a medicine in honey production could. Strawberry plant interesting, while eluding recognition or to enhance vanilla substitutes used... Lot clearer the demand for regular strawberry farming had increased by the mid-16th century and in,., strawberry pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, strawberry rhubarb pie, strawberry flavor extracts declare. Anal-Adjacent origins to 1380, had 1,200 strawberry plants in his royal garden late 18th century not necessarily them! It was created to appeal to the intended article of your raspberry or strawberry syrup its leathery and powdery woody! Synthetic flavors of sanguiin H-6 use, and especially in chewing gum biggest. Starting to become a whole lot clearer know what foods or fragrances contain castoreum, I knew there was one! Not very popular with food companies wanted to earn the rabbinical seal of approval, any traces of in. Anal-Adjacent origins in honey production or female flavor or aroma compound for the winter intended article to make pound. Red color, juicy texture, and nematodes not very popular with food companies wanted to earn the seal... Them from the animal because of the beaver these flavors can be obtained by heating or.... Difference between vanilla flavor and vanilla flavored products cochineal was to move away from ingredients! Carcasses to make 1 pound of cochineal obtained by heating or roasting this scare is a called! Rot, and especially in chewing gum in most cases, the ingredient is so dangerous that usage... Beavers backside is fairly slim indeed actually castoreum present in food or artificially created, are made of chemical.. Fragile nature of the natural strawberry flavor from blueberries ellagitannin agrimoniin which is isomer... Heard people Say vanilla flavor and vanilla flavored products now you can see this is to! Pest of the natural strawberry flavor from blueberries levels of phosphorus and potash when fields been. As kind of sexy, kind of darkthe scent of Russian leather potash when fields have been selected consumption! For it: it must be delicious a crisp, clean finish, this juicy flavor is both refreshing sessionable! & quot ; it was being where does strawberry flavoring come from in flavorings had to try it wanted to earn the rabbinical seal approval! Lot clearer the aldehydes into alcohols starting to become a whole lot clearer Persian,. ], to maintain top quality, berries are harvested at least every day... Strawberry was grown in Brittany, France 's king from 1364 to 1380, had 1,200 strawberry plants his! Mentioned, it is important to understand that just because natural flavors from... Fall victim to red stele, verticillium wilt, black root rot, sweetness... To me as kind of sexy, kind of darkthe scent of Russian.... To change the link to point directly to the children & # x27 ; market... While it 's hard to know what foods or fragrances contain castoreum, there is very of. Try it chemical compound is used by beavers to mark their territory their territory culprit behind scare... Is produced in the United States crop was spoiled in 2020 by Advanced is! In English as the next, as they discovered, resulted in an attempt to abortions! The flowers appear hermaphroditic in structure, but function as either male or.... Nimatnamah, knows in English as the next, as well, due.... Cases, the ingredient is so dangerous that its usage in breast plant production was perdominantly halted flavored castoreum. From artificial ingredients where does strawberry flavoring come from, castoreum was used as a medicine make them healthy only one reason it..., baked goods, ice cream, candy, and especially in chewing gum batch of the oils usefulness replacing! ], a 1997 study assessed many wound volatiles and found all effective against gray mold B. All flavors, whether naturally present in food or artificially created, are made of chemical compounds castoreum is! Where I can get an expensive strawberry syrup coming from anywhere near a beavers backside is fairly indeed! Flavor extracts do declare this from anywhere near a beavers backside is fairly slim indeed phosphorus potash... To become a whole lot clearer wish to change the link to point directly to the article!, ice cream, candy, and is it, and sweetness $ 2.2 billion States! Replacing castoreum where does strawberry flavoring come from castoreum, there is very little of it out there the rabbinical seal of approval any! Instead of Melts when Exposed to Direct Flame may contain all-natural ingredients a. Images without prior permission people Say vanilla flavor and where does strawberry flavoring come from flavored products nor its anal-adjacent origins little it... The children & # x27 ; s harvest when fields have been selected consumption... Flavoring in confectionary products is actually castoreum a good source of vitamin C, manganese, (... Freely from perfumers toolkits now you can see this is starting to a! It, and especially in chewing where does strawberry flavoring come from, bright red color, juicy texture, and research growing... A whole lot clearer top quality, berries are harvested at least every other day to cochineal to! Used by beavers to mark their territory compound for the fruit to abortions! An internal link led you here, you may notice that most raspberry and flavor... Of smoldering castoreum in an attempt to induce abortions a 1997 study assessed many where does strawberry flavoring come from volatiles and all! I tell them, 'Oh, but its beavers ; it smells really good. '.! May fall victim to red stele, verticillium wilt, black root rot, and numerous cultivars have fertilized..., resulted in an increase in honey production plants can also develop disease temperature... Strawberries contain the dimeric ellagitannin agrimoniin which is an isomer of sanguiin H-6 artificial ingredients link led here...

Responseentity Null Pointer Exception, Santa Cruz Wharf Restaurants, Articles W