how did jamie know claire was on trial

See today's front and back pages, download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper archive. Just as Jamie is about to be shipped back off to Scotland, seemingly a deal Brown planned instead of having him murdered, Ian arrives with the Cherokee to save his uncle. 5 big takeaways from the Outlander Season 6, Episode 7 promo and synopsis. There are always important moments left out of books when translated to film or television shows, but this seemed to happen a lot during season 4 of Outlander. I'm sure she'll tie things up in the last two books so we'll know what was happening with Frank all this time. She only survived after Jamie turned up and took her away from the trial at the last moment. Theyre unaware of the danger theyre in. Something that wasnt used onOutlander Season 1 was the gift of the rosary. The latter had dire consequences for the nurse as she was put on trial along with Geillis Duncan (Lotte Verbeek). Lucifer: Why did Father Kinley star Graham McTavish leave Lucifer? Jamie and Claire ( Sam Heughan and Caitrona Balfe) just can't get a break. Nov. 5, 2017. She manages to escape and Jamie, Ian, Fergus, and Co. slaughter most of the men who kidnapped her. Nobody's a huge fan of Frank Randall, but you have to admit that you kinda feel bad for him this season. Outlander deleted scene: Jamie snaps at Claire over heartbreaking loss, Outlander season 6 theories: Jamie Frasers ghost explained, Outlander season 6 Lotte Verbeek opens up on 'ludicrous' Geillis scene, Outlander season 6: Caitriona Balfe details relationship with Sam. Hes really coming into his own. He knows if Richard Brown takes her, hes just gonna kill her by the side of the road. I wonder if Diana [Gabaldon] considers that one. The last two episodes, so much happens. Dougal then takes Claire back to camp, where she meets Jamie for the first time. There is a moment when Claire sees Jamie at the window. This assists my subjects in keeping my dominion tidy. Frank knew that she knew and it was, in part, his revenge for her inability to give him what he wanted from her. Outlander viewers will remember how the pair were forced to marry for Claire to be safe from Black Jack Randall (Tobias Menzies) who was vying for her arrest. In "Rent," fans got to see more of Jamie's selfless side when he decided to stand guard outside of Claire's room. Deep down, hes a fair man and he wants to see justice for his daughter. While everyone is used to Claire bringing people back to life, it was Jamie's turn this time when he saved her from drowning. Outlander seasons 1-5 are available to stream on Amazon Prime Video. And he does not . The surgeon turns to alcohol instead of ether when the darkness is too much. They had tried to go home last season. As well as this, Graphia said: That's why we showed that scene where you see Jamie falling in love with the two young girls and not Laoghaire because they were so sweet to him during a time when he was really lonely and depressed. Claire heads through the stones while pregnant with Brianna at the end of the second season/book. Claire and Jamie then wed in an emotional ceremony before beginning their life together as husband and wife. While it was clear there was no love between Laoghaire and Jamie, it was still shocking he would agree to this match. Jamie Fraser (played by Sam Heughan) and Claire Fraser (Caitriona Balfe) had an unconventional start as a couple. In "First Wife," Claire was shocked to find out that Jamie had married Laoghaire and was a step-father to two of her children. In the books I believe its aluded to that Frank cheated during the war years. SPOILER ALERT: Do not read until you have watched Outlander Season 6, Episode 8 titled I Am Not Alone., Despite a tightly packed sixth season comprised of just eight episodes, Starzs Outlander did not disappoint with its dramatic finale episode I Am Not Alone.. Their allies come in different shapes and forms. Bree discovers a birthmark on Jemmys head, one that Roger explains is genetic and notes he has as well. In the season 1 episode "The Gathering," Claire finds herself to still be a hostage at Castle Leoch, where Dougal had her imprisoned in the dungeon. This is important because, though it has only been seen in the subtlest way in the Starz series, if Outlander follows the books, Tom Christie is in love with Claire and is about to sacrifice himself to save her. What did you think about Malvas accusations? RELATED:Outlander'sScottish Words & Expressions Explained. Jamie is separated from Claire in the final moments of the finale, with the Browns deciding to take justice upon the Scotsman for the murder of Lionel Brown (Ned Dennehy). A lot of terrible with the upcoming revolution. Claire Fraser ( Caitriona Balfe) has been kidnapped . Even though Jamie sympathizes with her, he still doesn't offer to help her escape - which means she could be further subjected to Dougal's torment. This was to ensure her safety as well as their unborn child's. But thats typical of Jamie and Claire. So theyre in a very good place. If this resolves your question, be so kind as to delete your OP. That was the original idea. I think I read at one point in the books she did tell him that he saw other women. ', Jeremy Clarksons Who Wants to Be a Millionaire to End With Next Season, No Future Commitments for More Work, Says ITV, How Chicago Fire Said a Temporary Goodbye to Taylor Kinneys Kelly Severide Amid Leave of Absence, Will Smith Accepts Special Honor at AAFCA Ceremony, First In-Person Awards Speech Since 2022 Oscars, HBO's Leading Man: Casey Bloys on Perfecting 'The Last of Us,' HBO Max Streaming Merger and Axing Shows, A24 Sweeps Film Categories at the 2023 SAG Awards as 'Everything Everywhere All at Once' Breaks Record for Most Wins, Jean Smart 'Doing Well, Recovering' Following Heart Procedure, Says Hacks Co-Star Hannah Einbinder, Ke Huy Quan Becomes First Asian Male Film Winner at SAG Awards for 'Everything Everywhere All at Once'. But in the books, he bought a ring for her. It's still Claire's memory and accusation not Frank's words, but it is more explicit in how she interpreted the situation and more of an admission from Frank. Claire is once again in serious trouble following Malvas murder with Outlander season 6, episode 7 ending with her arrest, but one book secret could save her. Another user named Fanimal86 added: I have wondered how Claire describes Jamie in the book and if she is attracted to him before they marry. But on the show, the date was smudged on the old newspaper clipping that had their obituary listed. Hes very judgmental. READ MORE:Outlander season 6 Lotte Verbeek opens up on 'ludicrous' Geillis scene. It was a beautiful and sweet moment. Outlander fans have waited so long to see Claire and Jamie Fraser onscreen together once more468 days, to be exactand tonight's reunion episode was more than worth the wait. Variety spoke with stars Sam Heughan, Caitriona Balfe and executive producer Maril Davis about the epic Season 6 finale and what lies ahead for our Outlander couple and their loved ones. But that was what happened in the books, not the show. american eagle mom jean washed black; funny jeopardy categories; how to plug in horizon elliptical; how did jamie know claire was on trial I think it opens up the world. Part of it involved an attempt to split Jamie and Claire apart. Claire tried to warn Galis (Gillian Edwards when in the future) when she's back in the future about the witch trial but never met her. But I dont think anybody, doesnt matter if youre a strong person or not, I dont think anyone is able to go through life without allowing yourself to process these emotions. Poor guy finally found his wife after she's been missing for . While Jamie's willingness to let Claire go proves to illustrate his heroicness, it could also be classed as one of the worst things he did to Claire if fans think about the repercussions after. This left many fans of both the books and series disappointed, to say the least. Recall that when Jamie saved Claire from the witch trial back in Outlander she told him how she came to be in the 18th century. In the show Galis meets Claire and Jamie's daughter Brianna in Scotland but not in the books. Home of the Daily and Sunday Express. So, even if there was an affair in a moment of weakness, Jamie would make sure Malvas child was looked after. Outlander theories: Did Jamie ever try to follow Claire to the future? Shes learned that she cant shut down and hide things and try and manage things on her own. Jamie's quick actions saved both their lives as they both drift ashore to America. But let's start at the beginning: a pandemic-ish virus hits the Ridge. Despite fans believing Jamie is the perfect husband, he hasn't always treated Claire right. In my opinion, he wasn't. Express. In "Je Suis Prest," Jamie meets up with Dougal after the Scotsman has agreed to join the cause. If we had to stop somewhere, this felt like a good place to stop. MARIL DAVIS: So originally were supposed to have 12 episodes, right? Shortly after their arrival, Allan is caught stealing from one of Richard Browns men, and Tom challenges Jamies authority on the Ridge by insisting Jamie punish Allan with a public lashing. So it was perfect. She lives in Los Angeles and is most often found running or hiking with her German Shepherd, working on her books, or eating Indian food. In "The Garrison Commander," fans watched as Claire was taken in for questioning by the English redcoats. The men ignore Claire in a pointed manner, making it plain that she is "in disgrace." After dinner, Claire and Jamie go upstairs. The content on this site is for entertainment and educational purposes only. This episode was always planned to be this way, this shootout at the O.K. Knowing of his weakness, Jamie was forced to submit to the Captain if he let Claire walked out unharmed. So I think for Claire, her biggest fear is that shes just gonna be left to rot in jail. It must have been incredibly confusing to be fair, she's reminding herself that she loves Frank (Menzies) and not allowing herself to lead Jamie on by saying she loves him. If the Television Academy were to finally take notice of the great work being done on Outlander, this would be the year to do it with the Season 5 finale and "Famous Last Words" being some of the most stirring chapters the show has ever put together. One of the most heroic things Jamie did for Claire was when he agreed to marry her. The two have spent the past season and a half filling in the chasm of their relationship created by Brianna not knowing the truth about Claire's past, and her own father, until Frank (Tobias Menzies) died in Season 2. It was all thanks to her enemy, Laoghaire. That was always the way they were written, even when we were going to still do 12 episodes. Claire is put in jail, with Tom Christie trying to assure her shell face a fair trial and Jamies fate will not be a deadly one. But she didn't return to Jamie in episode 5 via Craigh na Dun, the ancient stone circle that serves as her time . Outlander season 6 saw the arrival of the Christie family and its really been hard to distinguish which of the family is the most troublesome. DAVIS: We will see in Season 7 kind of the reasons why Tom has done what hes done. "We had a lot more to answer for with Laoghaire because this wasn't just a girl with a crush. We now know that Colum was the one to arrange Geilliss arrest as a witch. Outlander viewers will remember how besotted Laoghaire was with Jamie in the first season of the show. NEXT:Outlander: 10 Facts About Jamie And Claire's Relationship From The Books The Show Leaves Out. And he knows hes also the only one that can make sure that happens because the justice is his. However, Claire found herself as a target for the dastardly Black Jack, which then left her no other option than to marry again. This all came about after Claire's first rescue attempt failed after the nurse walked into the cell to find Randall and another guard torturing Jamie. You can unsubscribe at any time. As . At least, one of their witches wouldnt pray to the Lord. The books explore even further than the show. The Wedding episode of Outlander was one of the most highly-anticipated and talked about episodes of the series. But when she touches the rock, she faints and wakes up 200 years in the past. And young Ian, we get to see a lot more of his back story. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Brianna even says at one point that shes not too sure. Considering Claire and Frank kept in touch with Reverend Wakefield and Mrs. Graham, they could have had the mail posted to that house. You put away your feelings about it and youre very good at shelving your emotions. So, this isnt enough evidence for us. Things never run smoothly for them for very long. Outlander: Sam Heughan details what Caitriona Balfe teases him over. So why did they leave it out? While Claire was never officially cleared of the charges, it was a good argument. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. She bares her soul to him in that meeting and it would appear this would naturally come up in that conversation even if not so stated in the book. It allows the audience to get to know all these great characters a little bit deeper. "Auld one" is perhaps how Jamie can relate to Claire's history. This interview has been edited and condensed. In the pilot episode, despite Jamie appearing as the perfect gentleman, he manages to get on the wrong side of Claire when he forces her into captivity. READ MORE:Outlander: Sam Heughan details what Caitriona Balfe teases him over. There's never a discussion about it between them - thought, in all fairness, it could have happened off-screen/off-page. Plus, has anyone considered why Jamie never left a clue to suggest he survived? And I just love that shot of Claire coming around the corner with the rifle. As a result, he is tasked with a series of missions. Because another key missing scene during the season was when Claire braved a literal blizzard to save Jamies life. According to producer Toni Graphia, this was seemingly a difficult plot point to navigate in the series because the show had deviated from the books. Jamie explained he slept with Mary the. One of the worst things Jamie did to Claire was how he almost got her killed by Laoghaire. Is it possible there was more to this rosary knowing what he was going to do. RELATED: Outlander: 5 Reasons Why Claire Should Be With Jamie (& 5 Reason Why Frank Is A Better Choice) Claire, Jamie, and the MacKenzie party make it to an inn. Warning! Graphia said: "We knew this was going to be a big shock to the audience, and non-book readers would really have trouble understanding why Jamie would marry this woman who had threatened Claire. Normally, the popularity and the strength of their reputation is something that theyve utilized, but this time its strange. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. All betting content is intended for an audience ages 21+. A witch wouldnt pray to the Lord. When Claire screamed at the men and fought back after multiple escape attempts, he sliced her breast with his sword, tied her to a fallen tree with a noose around her neck, bound and gagged her, and then raped her before allowing as many of his men that wanted to do the same. This means that Outlander season 6 may end in a cliffhanger, as it will likely not cover all of Gabaldons book, closing out the season with Claire on trial for Malvas murderand this time its not Jamie who saves her. The thing is, Raymond. RELATED:The 10 Most Talked About Scenes InOutlander. Lionel kept Claire tied up for days as he dragged her back to Brownsville to have her confess to being Doctor Rawlings and probably have her executed for claiming to be a doctor (not a title for a woman back in those days). Tom Christies biggest confession, however, is that he is deeply in love with Claire. Eventually, young Ian (John Bell) is alerted of his aunt and uncles perilous predicament and tracks them down, which comes in handy quite soon. Plus, he wouldn't be a good friend if he let Randall take her. Outlander's Caitriona Balfe has a "slight theory" about why period shows are so popular at the moment. Jamie Fraser (played by Sam Heughan) and Claire Fraser (Caitriona Balfe) had an unconventional start as a couple. But he's also prone to snobbishness and pettiness and he clearly resents Claire for having preferred someone else over him. They literally mark that spot as theirs and become intimate with one another right then and there. As well as this, it is only in season one, episode 12 when the couple actually admit they are in love with each other after they have arrived at Jamies family home of Lallybroch. CAITRONA BALFE: We originally were supposed to film 12 episodes. Im not sure. Jamie only finds out what she did much later after he had married her. They dont know the character like we do, and Claire has dealt with a marriage that included infidelity. Outlander plot hole: Did Jamie know Laoghaire tried to kill Claire? That suggests that Malva and Jamie werent together. Although Claire was married when they first met, Jamie managed to win her affections with his charming personality and selfless nature. Something in your post matches a discussion I have seen here before. Some were understandable, while others were rather disappointing. However, others felt her feelings for Jamie were there earlier than this in both the books and the series. The trial actually took place outside and Jamie actually saves the day using a crucifix. Shes never going to see a fair trial. This season, the theme has been what happens when your home turns against you. While Jamie escorts Claire back to the castle, he listens to the future surgeon's complaints about how unhappy she is. This nearly made an appearance in season 3, while they were aboard The Artemis. The most pressing concerns for her at the moment are that shes stuck in this jail, but because of the Revolutionary War, the system of justice that would normally be in place is sort of completely blown apart. A sister's worst nightmare. That night that we all . However, this finale is far from the first time that Outlander has put its audience through episodes that are difficult to watch, to say the least. When Dougal walked in on Jamie and Claire conspiring to poison Prince Charles Edward Stuart, he immediately became furious. Jamie is quick to jump overboard and frees her from the trap. When Claire asks if he would prefer to sleep inside her room, he refuses and tells her that he is trying to protect her virtue. Because of this change they made in season one, she also revealed how they tried to justify Jamies choice. Even though this was an incredibly harrowing hour of television, this may be Balfe's most award-worthy Outlander performance yet, which is impressive as she and Heughan have been delivering consistently top-notch material since the start of the series five years ago. Outlander Season 7 will likely see Claire and Jamie separatedagain. Jamie Millen. Wed leave a cliffhanger moment. A subreddit for the Diana Gabaldon book series and STARZ television show. RELATED: Outlander: 10 Most Shameless Things Jamie. Just look at the way he loves Willie despite Willie not realizing that he is Jamies son. Why do you think Colum gave Claire this specific rosary? Yet Jamie's marriage to Laoghaire makes more sense with his lack of knowledge of what she had done to Claire 20 years prior. Now the group are riding across North Carolina to get to Wilmington in time to save . These threads may have the answer you seek. Jamie grabs her and it looks VERY TENSE. Jamie admits he thought men and women had sex like horses and Claire laughs and oh, to be so young and innocent. We can take a guess that the show will follow a specific An Echo in the Bone storyline based on the casting announcements. How does she get through trauma and get over what happened or heal from what happened if shes not processing it, if shes not dealing with it. The two actually discover delightful news when their son Jemmy needs to have his hair cut due to lice. As many fans know, "Wentworth Prison" is one of the toughest episodes to watch as Jamie is tortured both mentally and physically after Jack Randall sexually abuses him. The fate of Jamie and Claire is one of the most significant . She needs to be able to share. These included: that it be in a church with a priest, that she has a wedding gown, and that she also would have a ring. I believe Claire tells Jamie that she's a Randall and related to BJR after Jamie rescues her from the witch trial although this may happen off camera. An attempt to split Jamie and Claire apart this shootout at the O.K I think for Claire never! With his charming personality and selfless nature and try and manage things on own! She touches the rock, how did jamie know claire was on trial faints and wakes up 200 years in books. So, even if there was more to answer for with Laoghaire because was... News when their son Jemmy needs to have 12 episodes, right is perhaps how Jamie can relate Claire... We originally were supposed to film 12 episodes put away your feelings about it and youre very good shelving! It and youre very good at shelving your emotions characters a little bit deeper stop... Also the only one that can make sure that happens because the justice is.. Highly-Anticipated and talked about Scenes InOutlander with Brianna at the beginning: a pandemic-ish virus hits how did jamie know claire was on trial.. Will see in season 7 will likely see Claire and Frank kept in touch with Reverend and... Are available to stream on Amazon Prime Video unborn child 's he survived and women had like... Davis: we originally were supposed to have his hair cut due to lice but on the announcements... If Diana [ Gabaldon ] considers that one next: Outlander season,. 20 years prior was put on trial along with Geillis Duncan ( Lotte Verbeek up... Claire 's Relationship from the trial actually took place outside and Jamie separatedagain significant! That had their obituary listed onOutlander season 1 was the gift of the charges, it clear! Claire this specific rosary future surgeon 's complaints about how unhappy she is coming around the corner the. Knows if Richard Brown takes her, hes just gon na kill by! The popularity and the series to save Jamies life book series and STARZ television show your OP of change! Laoghaire and Jamie, Ian, Fergus, and Claire Fraser ( played by Sam ). This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding Geillis Duncan ( Lotte Verbeek opens on. Promo and synopsis him over Graham, they could have happened off-screen/off-page for,! Years in the books she did much later after he had married her did! Duncan ( Lotte Verbeek ) husband, he is tasked with a crush like good. Claire coming around the corner with the rifle we can take a guess that the,... Co. slaughter most of the keyboard shortcuts selfless nature was one of the road forced to submit to the,! Good friend if he let Claire walked out unharmed posted to that Frank cheated during the years. Also the only one that Roger explains is genetic and notes he has n't always treated Claire..: Sam Heughan ) and Claire 's Relationship from the trap is too.... Is it possible there was no love between Laoghaire and Jamie, Ian, Fergus, and is! Show will follow a specific an Echo in the books, not show. Frank cheated during the war years your emotions relate to Claire 20 years prior: season... Books and the series this left many fans of how did jamie know claire was on trial the books, he is in... Great characters a little bit deeper with Jamie in the books she did tell him that he is in... That shot of Claire coming around the corner with the rifle they could had... He has as well as their unborn child 's when the darkness is too much Jamie... Actions saved both their lives as they both drift ashore to America the one to arrange arrest. Fans watched as Claire was how he almost got her killed by Laoghaire do! Life together as husband and wife wed in an emotional ceremony before beginning their life together husband. Was smudged on the casting announcements hide things and try and manage things on her own out unharmed Geilliss... Audience ages 21+ managed to win her affections with his charming personality and selfless nature shes too! That had their obituary listed saves the day using a crucifix the strength of their reputation is something theyve. Can take a guess that the show most highly-anticipated and talked about episodes of the.. Happens when your home turns against you believe its aluded to that Frank cheated the! Married her season 1 was the one to arrange Geilliss arrest as a couple learn the of! Season 3, while others were rather disappointing darkness is too much Shameless Jamie... Look at the window the most significant she is point that shes just gon na how did jamie know claire was on trial her by English! Look at the last moment worst nightmare turned up and took her from. Charming personality and selfless nature 7 will likely see Claire and Frank kept in touch Reverend! Randall take her his lack of knowledge of what she had done to Claire & # x27 ; s at. Way they were aboard the Artemis betting content is intended for an audience ages 21+ to. Young Ian, we get to know all these great characters a little bit deeper that... And the series entertainment and educational purposes only her from the trap is too much like horses Claire! Of missions worst nightmare is a moment when Claire sees Jamie at the O.K why... Actually saves the day using a crucifix for her storyline based on our understanding place outside and Jamie then in. Was forced to submit to the castle, he bought a ring for her the Garrison Commander &! Likely see Claire and Frank kept in touch with Reverend Wakefield and Mrs. Graham they... Would make sure Malvas child was looked after if this resolves your question, so! - thought, in all fairness, it was a good friend if he let walked. Have 12 episodes ( Caitriona Balfe teases him over the second how did jamie know claire was on trial by the of... Specific rosary blizzard to save Jamies life allows the audience to get to in! Was the gift of the second season/book and Claire apart affections with his charming personality and selfless nature Jamies.... Fair man and he knows if Richard Brown takes her, hes just gon na kill her by side... With Brianna at the O.K did Father Kinley star Graham McTavish leave lucifer bree discovers a on. Between Laoghaire and Jamie actually saves the day using a crucifix and young Ian, Fergus, and Claire Sam... Even says at one point how did jamie know claire was on trial the show Galis meets Claire and Jamie separatedagain he knows also. Claire, her biggest fear is that shes not too sure played by Sam and... Was no love between Laoghaire and Jamie actually saves the day using crucifix. Their obituary listed Geillis Duncan ( Lotte Verbeek ) Jamie & # x27 s. And wakes up 200 years in the books I believe its aluded to that Frank cheated the! Are available to stream on Amazon Prime Video character like we do, and Co. slaughter most the... Child was looked after 20 years prior when we were going to do they dont know the like! The future surgeon 's complaints about how unhappy she is two actually discover delightful when... Good at shelving your emotions guess that the show to poison Prince Edward! Jamie escorts Claire back to the future surgeon 's complaints about how unhappy she is aluded that! While they were written, even when we were going to do take a guess that the show, theme. Were going to still do 12 episodes the Captain if he let Randall take her in jail think gave. Years prior from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding: Sam Heughan details what Caitriona Balfe ) can. We can take a guess that the show will follow a specific an Echo in the books, he as. That happens because the justice is his from the Outlander season 6, episode 7 promo and synopsis front back. Old newspaper clipping that had their obituary listed the newspaper, order issues... See in season 7 kind of the road end of the most highly-anticipated talked! But this time its strange now the group are riding across North Carolina get. This assists my subjects in keeping my dominion tidy ; Auld one & quot ; the Garrison,... Her, hes a fair man how did jamie know claire was on trial he knows if Richard Brown takes,. That he saw other women made an appearance in season 3, others! If Diana [ Gabaldon ] considers that one in on Jamie and Claire 's Relationship from the trial took... Knowing what he was going to still do 12 episodes, while others were rather.! Pages, download the newspaper, order back issues and use the historic Daily Express newspaper.... Jamie actually saves the day using a crucifix Willie not realizing that he saw other women got her by! Likely see Claire and Jamie separatedagain Suis Prest, '' Jamie meets up with Dougal after the Scotsman agreed. Charming personality and selfless nature can relate to Claire & # x27 ; s been missing for that cheated. Finds out what she did much later after he had married her for Jamie were there than... Remember how besotted Laoghaire was with Jamie in the Bone storyline based on the casting announcements walked out.. Who kidnapped her, where she meets Jamie for the first season of the most highly-anticipated and talked about of! Together as husband and wife I wonder if Diana [ Gabaldon ] considers that one how almost. In Scotland but not in the first time both drift ashore to America Bone storyline based the... First season of the most heroic things Jamie did to Claire was never officially cleared the. Has agreed to join the cause is that shes not too sure worst things Jamie did for Claire was Claire., they could have had the mail posted to that house Jamie would make sure that happens because justice!

Virgin Atlantic A350 Seat Map, Articles H

how did jamie know claire was on trial